Colorado homeowners insurance — compare your policy
Insurance · Colorado · Our partner

Colorado Homeowners Insurance: Premiums Up, Carriers Leaving, Coverage Full of Gaps

Your renewal came in higher again. Maybe the carrier dropped you, or told you they're done writing your zip code. Hail on the Front Range, wildfire pricing in the mountains, and a policy nobody has actually read since the day you bought the house. Our insurance partner compares the carriers still writing Colorado and finds the gaps in what you have now. It takes a few minutes to start, and it costs nothing to look.
01 / PREMIUM WENT UP
Find out what the other carriers charge
02 / DROPPED OR NON-RENEWED
We know who still writes your area
03 / HAIL AND WILDFIRE
Priced by people who write Colorado
04 / GAPS FOUND FIRST
The review before the claim
Start here

When Was the Last Time Anyone Actually Compared Your Policy?

For most Colorado homeowners the answer is the day they bought the house. The renewal shows up every year with a bigger number, it gets paid, and nobody asks whether the carrier that wrote a policy years ago is still the right one. Hail on the Front Range and wildfire pricing in the mountains have changed what every carrier charges, and they haven't all changed the same way.

If you're in the middle of a loan with me, this isn't optional. The lender won't fund without a bound policy, and a policy that comes in higher than anyone planned changes the payment, the ratios, and sometimes the approval. So our insurance partner runs the comparison in week one, while there's still time to do something about it.

What people get wrong, and what's true:

  • 01

    "My lender handles the insurance."

    Your lender requires it. Nobody on the lending side shops it. That gap is where signing days slip.

  • 02

    "I'll just keep my current carrier."

    You can, and sometimes you should. But you'll know that because it was compared, not because it was easier.

  • 03

    "Insurance is a signing-day detail."

    It's a payment detail. The premium goes in your escrow and your monthly. On a mountain purchase it can be the line that decides the offer.

  • 04

    "If I can't get coverage, the bank will put something on it."

    The bank will. It's called force-placed insurance, it costs far more, and it covers the lender, not you. We don't let a file get there.

The review

What Patrick Looks for in a Policy You Already Have

Most policies get renewed, not read. Patrick reads them. In a few minutes he walks through a real one the way he does for every file our partner handles: what's covered, what isn't, and where the gaps are that nobody notices until there's a claim.

Replacement cost that hasn't kept up with the house. Roof coverage that pays less every year. Wildfire and hail exclusions buried in the endorsements. Liability limits from a decade ago.

Watch it, then pull your own declarations page. If you find yourself checking line by line, that's the comparison starting.

How Patrick Reviews a Homeowners Policy for Gaps

A real review, from the licensed agent our partner puts on your file.

What it takes

What Happens When the Policy Is on the Same Calendar as the Loan?

On a file with three strangers, insurance is the last call anyone makes. The buyer remembers it the week before signing, the first quote is the only quote, and if the number is bad there's no time left to fix it. On a refinance or a reverse mortgage it's the renewal that never got looked at, now sitting in an escrow analysis.

When the loan and the policy run on one calendar, our insurance partner has the property the same week I do. Here's what that does for you.

What that looks like in practice:

  • 01

    The premium in the math early.

    The real quote lands before the strategy goes on paper, so your payment is your payment, not an estimate with an asterisk.

  • 02

    Coverage where carriers are pulling back.

    In wildfire-rated areas and hail zones, some companies have stopped writing. Our partner knows which ones still do, and what mitigation moves the price.

  • 03

    Replacement cost that satisfies the lender.

    Reverse mortgages and jumbo files have specific coverage requirements. The policy is written to them the first time, not rewritten under a deadline.

  • 04

    Bound before signing day.

    The binder is in the file before the lender asks for it. Nothing stalls.

Bobby Friel, CO Home Equity

I've watched a signing day move a week because nobody shopped the insurance. It's the cheapest problem on the file to prevent and the most annoying one to fix.

— Bobby Friel · CO Home Equity

CALIBRATED QUESTION

If the policy were quoted and bound in the first week instead of the last, what else on your file would stop being a worry?

Fit

Should Our Partner Run Your Comparison?

Usually, when:

  • You're buying, refinancing, opening a HELOC, or taking a reverse mortgage with me, and the lender needs a policy.

  • Your renewal jumped and nobody has compared it in years.

  • The house is in a hail or wildfire-rated area and you've been told coverage is hard to get.

  • You'd rather have one person watching the loan and the policy on the same calendar.

Usually not, when:

  • You need commercial coverage. That's a different desk, and I can point you to it.

  • Your policy was compared this year and the lender has the binder. You're done; keep it.

  • You want a rate quote with no file behind it. Our partner quotes real properties for real loans, not hypotheticals.

Two files

How It Usually Goes

Illustrative, not specific clients

The mountain buyer whose first quote would have killed the offer.
FILE 01

The mountain buyer whose first quote would have killed the offer.

A Front Range couple under contract on a home in a wildfire-rated area got one quote from their old carrier and it was enough to break the payment. Our partner had the property the same week, found a carrier still writing that zone, and priced the mitigation the seller had already done. The premium went into the offer math instead of blowing it up. Signing day held.

The reverse mortgage that needed a different policy.
FILE 02

The reverse mortgage that needed a different policy.

A valley homeowner in her seventies had carried the same policy for decades. The reverse lender needed full replacement cost and the old policy didn't say so. Our partner rewrote it to the lender's requirement and compared the price while he was at it. The file funded on schedule, and the renewal came in lower than the one she'd been paying.

The process

From the First Week to the Binder

One handoff, early. Here's the order.

01

The first call

Whatever brought you here, a purchase, a refinance, a HELOC, a reverse mortgage, or a renewal that jumped. You leave with an action plan, and insurance is on it.

02

The handoff

With your okay, our insurance partner gets the property address and the loan's requirements. One form, or I send it. Nothing is shared without your say.

03

The comparison

Our partner runs the carriers that write your area, prices the coverage the lender needs, and comes back with the options and a recommendation.

04

The strategy

The premium goes into the payment on paper, next to the loan. If the number changes the plan, we know now, not the week of signing.

05

The binder, then signing day

Coverage is bound and in the file before the lender asks. On signing day the only surprise is the keys.

If you're not in a loan with me and just want the comparison, skip to step two. Our partner will run it either way.

Questions

Homeowners Insurance and Your Colorado Loan — Questions Answered

Yes. Every lender requires an active policy with the property, and usually with the lender named on it, before funding. No binder, no signing day. That's why our partner quotes it in the first week.
Coverage the lender buys on your house when you don't have your own. It costs far more than a policy you'd choose, and it protects the lender's interest, not yours. It's what happens when nobody shops the insurance in time.
Patrick Henigan and his team at Direct Insurance Services, a licensed Colorado agency. They compare many carriers on your behalf. I hold the mortgage and real estate licenses; they hold the insurance license. Your information goes to them only with your okay.
Usually, though some carriers have stopped writing certain zones and prices vary widely. Our partner knows which companies still write where, and what mitigation work lowers the premium. Start early; this is the part that takes time.
It needs a policy that covers full replacement cost and meets the lender's requirements. Many long-held policies don't say so. Our partner rewrites it to the requirement before the file is submitted.
No. Comparing is free and changes nothing. If the recommendation is to keep what you have, you keep it, and now you know it was the right call.
Usually a few days once our partner has the property and the loan's requirements. On a purchase it runs the same week the application does, so the premium is in the payment before you write.
Yes. If your renewal jumped or you've never had it compared, use the button on this page and our partner will run it. No loan required.
Bobby Friel — CO Home Equity Founder

Shop the policy the week the file opens.

I hold two licenses and neither of them is insurance, which is exactly why this page exists. I've been on enough files to know that the policy is where a smooth signing day goes sideways, and I've built the practice so it can't. Our insurance partner gets the property the same week I do.

I don't take a cut of the policy, and our partner doesn't work for a single carrier. The point isn't the commission; the point is that when I say "signing day," it's a real date.

If you're in a loan with me, this is already happening. If you're not, and your renewal just went up again, use the button and let them look.

Your policy

Get the Policy Compared Before Signing Day, Not After.

One handoff to our insurance partner, in the first week. The premium goes in your payment, the binder goes in your file, and nothing stalls.

Insurance is placed by our licensed insurance partner, not by CO Home Equity or Friel-Good Mortgage, Inc. Coverage for a business? Commercial insurance is handled at Insurance Service 365. Coverage, availability, and premiums vary by carrier, property, and location. Every figure on this page is an estimate until a carrier quotes your property.

Loans and home sales in Colorado handled by Bobby Friel, licensed mortgage broker and licensed real estate broker, based in Edwards and serving homeowners and buyers across Colorado. Insurance through our insurance partner, Direct Insurance Services. 42 five-star Google reviews. (720) 799-2202 · info@cohomeequity.com.

Bobby Friel · NMLS# 332039 · Friel-Good Mortgage, Inc. · NMLS# 1901977 · Edwards, Colorado